My Experience in CURR 423
My expectations were for an experience that would provide lots of practical ideas about how to teach in an urban school … which implies that we would also develop a good understanding of what makes urban schools different from suburban/rural schools.
My expectations were exceeded. In particular, the seven-schools-in-three-days experience was an amazing opportunity to address both of my expectations above.
I liked the way the experience was teed up, with our Assumptions exercise and Culture Collages: having us metacognitively establish our own frames-of-reference and then test the reality against that was an effective – even shocking – pedagogical technique (that I have added to my list of things I will certainly use when I am a teacher).
I liked the follow-up panel discussion when we returned to MSU. Not only did it seem like senior people at MSU actually, really, did want to hear what we thought, we were able to flesh out some of our observations and questions.
The biggest challenge for me in the class was my fear – OK, maybe my expectation – that this course would turn out to be a policy whinge about what’s wrong with NCLB, the Bush administration, people who made a lot of money, etc. The nicest surprise was how practical, useful, and important it was to understand the policy framework within which urban schools operate.
I was curious, on the way in, about how being a good urban teacher would be different from being a good teacher. I am taking away two important ideas:
Unlike the suburban schools I’m familiar with, where teachers, like students, are encouraged to fall in with The Program, in urban schools there is a premium put on personal enterprise. Many of the best practices we read about and saw were ad-hoc initiatives of individual teachers and, even more impressively, groups of teachers.
The need to make lessons relevant came up in a number of different contexts. While this is not unique to urban schools, it will be a real challenge for someone like me, who actually doesn’t know a lot about what urban adolescents listen to, watch, read, fear, dream about, hope for, etc. While learning about these are one of the reasons I plan to go into urban education, it was impressed on me that this isn’t a nice-to-have; it’s something I really need to get a handle on before entering the classroom.
The most helpful aspects of the course were:
The field experience.
The pedagogical techniques we used in class: the excellent syllabus, Culture Collage, blogs, and the group feedback sessions. I have made notes of these and will use them when I am a teacher.
The theoretical & political context readings/lectures. These made me aware, for the first time, that things like basic wellness and safety issues might be important factors that urban teachers need to be sensitive to. Equally importantly, it put some perspective on the challenge that awaits: after trying as hard as I can, I’m not going to beat myself up unnecessarily over things (way) beyond my control.
Although I would not be too hasty to fix what ain’t broke, I would think about two tweaks to the syllabus:
Requiring both blogs and a website seemed to direct a fair amount of our psychic energy into learning how to use new technologies, at the expense of additional content that we might have been able to learn. If we did free up some capacity I would have welcomed more exposure to …
I have a heightened sense of how little I know about the lived experience of urban adolescents. I would have liked additional readings or, better yet, direct interaction. The best 10 minutes of my MSU teacher training to date were spent with our outstanding eighth-grade host during our first school visit: the challenges as well as the opportunities/rewards of being involved with lives like that became searingly real. I wanted more.