Friday, May 23, 2008

Lies, damned lies, and Phi Delta Kappa

I should state, up front, my own biases about NCLB before responding to this report. I find many of the arguments made by both those in favor and those opposed to NCLB persuasive. In other words, I am confused. I think this conversation has only just begun; the issues need to be more crisply framed before we move to vote on them.

This report reads suspiciously like a survey devised by MSU faculty at the request of the teachers’ unions, to elicit responses that deride NCLB. Here’s one way to summarize the way the report summarizes the attitudes of the public toward NCLB:

The only people who think NCLB or its partner-in-crime standardized testing is any good are those who haven’t bothered to think about them. Don’t try to fool us with all these facts. We don’t have much confidence in vouchers, on-line learning, or even charter schools; give us our good ole system of teachers in a classroom. Just pay them more.

Obviously lop-sided polemics like this give comfort to the enemy of those who espouse the views in it.

Two facts are enough to make the survey suspect, and thus destroy its value as a potential arrow in the quiver of the anti-NCLB folks:

The composition of the sample: three-quarters of the respondents have no children in school!? More than 40% are over 50!? More than 80% are white!? Come on!!!

Dangerously ill-defined and profoundly loaded questions like that discussed in Table 5: “Would you rather judge schools based on some state-mandated test or “improvements students in the school made during the year?” “Improvements” … what does that mean!?

Thursday, May 22, 2008

Urban Teacher Bibliogrpahy

Bibliogrpahy

The Urban Teacher

McLaughlin, Milbrey W. and Joan E. Talbert, Professional Communities and the Work of Teaching High School (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2001).

The authors, Stanford University researchers, conducted detailed examinations of seven school districts to determine why a high school teacher was able or inspired to excel. They chose both urban and suburban districts in California, which is state-standards-oriented, and Michigan, which is highly decentralized.

They examined a number of factors and found that the key was to establish relevance for students. Moreover, schools had a shared responsibility with students to create this relevance, with both words receiving independent emphasis: schools had to hold themselves responsible and accountable for relevancy, while at the same time recognizing that this was impossible unless they partnered with students to do so.

The authors found that the key organizational implication was that teachers needed to take the initiative to form professional communities that oversaw the delivery of peer coaching, mentoring, equitable division of the work load, and designing curricula that was student-centered rather than constructed in the silo of a single subject department.

McLaughlin and Talbert identified a special opportunity for subject department heads to bring distinction to themselves in both organizing the above tasks and deflecting “district toxicity” from teachers.

The bottom line was that, in successful sub/urban schools, the team’s the thing; individual contributors are increasingly unable to accomplish the necessary and complex organizational tasks required.

Reviewers somewhat predictably acknowledged the validity of the authors’ observations, but groaned under the weight of yet-one-more burden teachers are expected to shoulder at their own initiative. (See, e.g., Karen Ferris-Fearnside, The History Teacher, 36, 3 (May, 2003), 419-20.)

= = =

Tredway, Lynda, “The Art of Juggling: Preparing Preservice Teachers for Urban Schools,” The Journal of Negro Education, 68, 3 (Summer, 1999), 382-396.

This upbeat essay describes a university-school partnership that prepares teachers for careers in Washington, DC’s urban high schools. The author, the project’s former director, likens the urban teacher challenge to that faced by a juggler. A curriculum that includes readings to develop a philosophical core, community experiences, and professional role-modeling is described. A guide to selecting interns with a high probability of success is provided. Particularly interesting for the students, faculty, administrators, and urban partners of Montclair State’s UTA.

= = =

Scappini, Robert A., “Teaching High School in the Context of Performance-Based Standards: An Innovative Approach for Urban Schools,” The History Teacher, 37, 2 (February, 2004), 183-91.

The author teaches History in an impoverished urban school in Rhode Island, a state that is moving toward a more standards-based environment. He has found success in reorienting his pedagogy from textbook-based to project-based. Projects provide opportunities to observe six successful pedagogical strategies: frequently informing students where they are in the overall lesson plan, breaking the lesson plan into manageable chunks, publicly displaying student work, bringing in guest experts, keeping student journals, and repeating the standards of historical thinking (chronological thinking, historical comprehension, historical issues, and analysis & interpretation, in support of decision-making.) A must for urban high school Social Studies teachers.

= = =

Green, Robert L. and Bradley R. Carl, “A Reform for Troubled Times: Takeovers of Urban Schools,” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 569 (May, 2000), 56-70.

The authors begin by identifying pros and cons in the strategy of a state takeover of an urban school. Those in favor point to the clarification of responsibility and accountability, the streamlining of the budgeting process, and the depoliticizing of school governance. Those opposed see takeovers as a racist denial of self-governance to minorities, and a process that rarely has either clearly identified rationales or strategies for returning control to the local community. Green and Carl examined two dozen takeovers and concluded that there is conflicting evidence about whether the schools improved. They identify the need for more comprehensive and objective data that relates to clear objectives in order to assess whether takeovers are an effective strategy. Particularly recommended for teachers in Newark, Jersey City, and other districts that have been “taken over by” the state.

= = =

Hughes-Hassell, Sandra and Pradnya Rodge, “The Leisure Reading Habits of Urban Adolescents,” Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 51, 1 (September, 2007), 22-34.

The authors establish two direct links between urban students’ leisure reading and success in high school: students who read on their own initiative are more likely to do well in school; and knowing what students read in their leisure time provides teachers with insights into how to construct engaging lesson plans. The detailed analysis performed by the authors suggest that urban students read more than we probably realize, but this is less likely to be books than magazines and websites relating to personal interests.

Assumptions

Intro

I have seen urban life, but only through a key hole: it’s a start but I need to open the door and get a really good look. I am different along a number of dimensions from many of the students I hope to teach. This is by design. I approach urban teaching from a very strong conceptual foundation, the construction of which has been one of the accomplishments of which I am most proud. I am deliberately seeking situations in which my students and I are radical Others, because that is a condition for the maximum construction of meaning, i.e. for maximum learning-education. This may be incredibly naïve.

Beliefs about urban …

… centers

• The environment is stimulating to the point of info-overload, which then gets force-fitted into patterns.

• Even not-so-bright urban dwellers have some degree of street-smarts (that make them potentially good students).

• There is an unending competition for everything, in every aspect of life, across all genders, classes, and races.

• There are extremes of having and needing.

… public schools

• Are physically cruddy; probably smelly.

• Are generally under-resourced, perhaps startlingly so.

• Have little sense of local control; there is a pervasive sense that Others are making decisions that impact me and we.

• There is a preoccupation with safety, psychic dissonance, physical plant, health, and eating that often leaves little time for Maslow’s higher-order niceties.

… teachers

• Are mostly local.

• Are relatively older.

• A core group of younger, dedicated, progressive teachers who want to improve the community they grew up in/near provide the de facto leadership.

• There are lots of clock-punchers just waiting to be pensioned off.

• There are too many long-suffering, martyr types.

• There are a noticeable number of eccentrics: people who find it difficult to fit in most places but who can find anonymity in a place that’s happy just to have a warm body in each teacher’s seat.

• There are a few young, irritating, ineffective self-appointed change agents who are really trying to impose their normatives onto the community.

… students

• They will have backgrounds, interests, skills, knowledge, mannerisms, modes of thinking, and realities that are different from mine, probably uncomfortably so.

• 45-60% are not terribly distinguished along any dimension.

• 15-25% either don’t want to be there in school or, worse, find in school a public stage ideally suited to acting out really unattractive personalities, attitudes, and ambitions.

• 15-25% are bright but do not have the obedience/inertia that suburbia installs in students to just shut up and finish high school and then do what you want. These students are on the fence and will become engaged if the class experience is interesting and relevant, but will remain disengaged if not.

• 5-15%, as the result of a variety of internal and external motivations, see school as a ticket to a more attractive place, and are thus motivated to see and grab the educational good that’s on offer, and are able to ignore the rest.

My confidence level in these assumptions is:

Pure fiction ___________________________X_________ Lived experience


The sources of my assumptions are my experiences living and working in a number of urban areas: Manhattan (8 years), Singapore (4), Rio de Janeiro (2), London (4), Kansas City (2). I was a Big Brother in “Alphabet City” on Manhattan’s Lower East Side for three years, which gave me first-hand insights into inner-city urban adolescents. I have four children who went to school in urban areas and live/work in New York City. I am humbly aware of the fact that some of the experiences on which I base my assumptions are 30 years old.

How might these assumptions affect my interactions with teachers and students, and affect the kind of classroom I hope to create?

With respect to the teachers, I plan to do what I did in my Wall Street career, when every three years or so I was reassigned to a new position/country: I will jump to some pretty quick decisions about which teachers fall into each of two horribly over-simplified buckets: 1) they are there because, although they have options, they want to be; 2) others. I will self-appoint the former my mentors, and will struggle to muster the gracefulness to politely ignore the others.

With respect to the students, I spent five years in a PhD program intensively studying how meaning is dialogically constructed. The process and attributes of genuine dialog are a kind of secular religion for me. This is at the core of how I hope to interact with the students, and has the following significant implications for urban students:

• The amount of meaning-making/truth constructed/learning-education is proportional to the differences between the dialog partners. Little or no learning takes place between very similar conversants. My students and I will be radically Other to each other. This is by design (assuming someone’s willing to hire me), and will provide for the maximization of the education-learning process. But only if …

• Genuine dialogs do not happen without open-mindedness and goodwill. I will try to both exhibit and encourage these “hermeneutic virtues” as the two paramount priorities of my classroom after physical and psychological safety.

• Each dialog partner enters the hermeneutic circle with a set of foregroundings that are a result of their nature and nurture. In a successful conversation, these biases are risked and expanded … which equals the learning-education. A classroom is not perfectly democratic, in that it is the teacher – moi – who gets to ask the question that starts the hermeneutic circle spinning. In order to ask the right questions, I need to understand my students’ foregroundings. This is the “Velcro” onto which I “stick” the lessons. I am relatively clueless about this. That is why I signed on for the Urban Teaching Academy. Professor Goldstein, you are one of a handful of people who can get me up-to-speed here. The mentor relationships inside my school that I will work hard to cultivate will be another, ongoing, source of help. Of course, listening to students is the greatest potential source of these insights.

Because I suspect I will unconsciously triage the students in the following manner I will try to consciously do so:

I will try to quickly identify the 15-25% who are shit-stirers and individually tell them the deal I am prepared to cut: I will try to make learning Social Studies as relevant and as interesting as anything else they do, if they explain to me what they find relevant and interesting. If that dialog proves unproductive, I will ask my mentors a) if I’m missing something, and b) how to neutralize those students so they don’t interfere with my ability to work with other students.

“Turning” the 15-25% who are on the fence would be a source of special satisfaction: I will dedicate myself to getting them excited about what I have to teach them, drawing on my own (fairly considerable) experience, the insights of my mentor-colleagues, and the other students.

The 5-15% who are genuinely motivated to learn are low-hanging fruit. I think providing them with extra challenges in class will require minimal extra effort on my part. Based on my Boys Club experience, I also expect to be able to introduce them to life-options beyond high school that they might want to think about. I view myself as a resource to these students, and would like to be fully taken advantage of.

I’m not terribly proud of myself for saying this, but beyond trying to make Social Studies relevant and engaging, I don’t plan to take a direct personal interest in the 45-60% who are essentially undistinguished.

How might these assumptions relate to the type of professional I hope to become?

Being of the “dialogic” religion, I believe that people might say the following kinds of things about me ten years from now:

• Mark worked well with his students’ other teachers, pooling their resources to triangulate on both high-potential and problem students to develop effective individual strategies for them.

• Mark’s students sensed that he knew how to hook his lessons onto other things in their lives that they found interesting and relevant. As such, they enjoyed learning in his class and were thereby able to get good grades and feel good about that portion of their academic experience.

• Mark’s students had an in-depth understanding of one of the most important insights of modernity: that knowledge is constructed in dialogs, and that these are only successful if the participants observe a small number of critical rules. The knowledge created is the private personal property of those who constructed it, and it has real – even economic – value. Understanding this one thing became important to how Mark's students thought about everything in their lives after high school. That was a lasting contribution that Mark had on his students.

• Mark did not burn himself out angsting over that which he would never have been able to accomplish anyway.

• Mark came to education late in life. He did not (have to) suffer fools among his colleagues and administrators. Too bad: he might have made a really good teacher.

Tuesday, May 20, 2008

Martin Haberman & Martin Heidegger

Probably the most important idea of the 20th century was Heidegger’s insight that truth is not “out there” waiting to be discovered by those who look for it hard or smart enough, or are divinely inspired. Instead, truth is constructed by individuals, in dialogs with Others (another person, a text, a work of art, etc).

Gadamer made Heidegger’s obscure notions accessible by using the “hermeneutic circle” to explain how truth/meaning is constructed. Conversants approach a dialog with going-in points-of-view determined by nature and nurture. In a genuine dialog – one in which new truth/meaning is constructed – dialog partners demonstrate open-ness and goodwill. They expose their going-in POVs to the Other … they risk their Selves. The process is not one of dukeing out whose POV will prevail; it is not meeting somewhere in the middle. Instead, each conversant’s POV/Self is expanded … in the direction of the Other.

The core of Haberman’s “good teaching” paradigm is informed by these Heideggerian insights.

Haberman “cannot emphasize enough” that classroom regimes designed around control are doomed to fail. The hermeneutic process of constructing meaning, as mentioned, is utterly dependent on the willingness of all parties to abandon their existing POVs and assume the risk of constructing a new Self. A model based on control is inimical to this requirement of genuine meaning-making.

“Whenever students are involved with human differences, good teaching is going on.” An important corollary of the process described above is that a turn around the hermeneutic circle with a dialog partner just like yourself isn’t going to result in the construction of much new meaning/truth/understanding. To move the needle requires that the Other being engaged is different. The degree of alterity determines the amount of meaning constructed. We hit the educational jackpot when we successfully engage the radically Other.

“Who is responsible for seeing that students derive meaning?” There’s plenty of blame that can be spread around for the failure of an educational system, i.e. for the failure to conduct genuine dialogs and thereby construct new meaning/truth/understanding: teachers, students, parents, administrations, communities. But teachers alone have the special opportunity to contrive lessons and classroom experiences that facilitate the hermeneutic-circle process and that allow their students to practice the “hermeneutic virtues” of goodwill and open-mindedness. Their reward is that, as a party to this process, their horizons, too, are expanded.

I believe this is the essence of what Haberman was talking about when he described “good teaching.”

Duh ... it's a movie!

Bulman has confused an entertainment genre with public policy.

It’s silly to assert that the attitudes of the majority of Americans about urban education – or anything else – are accurately depicted in the movies they watch. As Bulman notes on a number of occasions, movies are fantasy.

Bulman has provided us with (unoriginal) insights into how to construct successful boilerplate screenplays, not scholarship that bears on public policy with respect to urban education.

He wants us to know that the problems of urban schools and many other urban problems are less the result of the flawed values and character of the individuals who live there “and more the result of low levels of public investment in infrastructure, poor public housing, inadequate health care, poor schools, and a disappearing employment base.”

I, for one, am willing to accept that.

I am one of the millions of American moviegoers who will pay over and over again to watch a variation on the theme of the lone outsider who rides into town, rights all wrongs, and rides off into the sunset.

But I would not pay to see a movie about a disappearing employment base.

Bulman could have produced some useful scholarship if he had, instead of trying to make the case for why Americans’ favorite fantasies are accurate reflections of their public policy attitudes, gone in either of two different, but related, directions.

It would have been genuinely useful to know what the majority of middle-class taxpayers/voters really do think the big issues confronting urban schools are, and how those might be addressed. To do this Bulman would have had to conduct some kind of sociologically valid interview or survey.

Alternatively, having identified an attitude toward the problems of urban schools and how to address them, that he disagrees with, Bulman could have investigated whether current laws and policies have been crafted with that flawed attitude in mind. This could have suggested public policy alternatives.

What I want to know is whether our public policies reflect flawed thinking about the nature of urban problems, not whether our movies do.


Response to Annenberg essay

I was most struck by one aspect of the "Agency" section.  Although most of the discussion is about empowering students, the point that really stopped me in my tracks concerned teacher agency.  The specific passage was, "Teachers demonstrate agency when they take responsibility for the learning of every child and act as advocates for children against the pessimism that surrounds discussions of urban education."

This sounds, at first blush, somewhere between noble and innocuous.  But upon further reflection an almost seditious subtext is suggested.

One of the points of the article is that school districts themselves may contribute to the process of denying agency to students.  If I find myself working in such a district, and I take the Annenberg challenge to heart, I may find myself at loggerheads with my superiors.

I have no immediate thoughts about how I might negotiate my way through such a sticky wicket.  I suspect an urban teacher often finds him/herself between a dog's leg and fire hydrant in terms of competing demands from administrative types and the educational needs of students.  

The epiphany I had from reading this article is that I will need to have a list of high-gain questions to ask the various administrators, future colleagues, and students that I'll meet when I begin to interview for a job.  These questions will probe for potential constraints to my ability to exercise the kind of teacher-agency the Annenberg team advocates.  I'll try to avoid schools that appear to conspire against my exercising such agency and, instead, look for schools that seem to thrive on it.