Bulman has confused an entertainment genre with public policy.
It’s silly to assert that the attitudes of the majority of Americans about urban education – or anything else – are accurately depicted in the movies they watch. As Bulman notes on a number of occasions, movies are fantasy.
Bulman has provided us with (unoriginal) insights into how to construct successful boilerplate screenplays, not scholarship that bears on public policy with respect to urban education.
He wants us to know that the problems of urban schools and many other urban problems are less the result of the flawed values and character of the individuals who live there “and more the result of low levels of public investment in infrastructure, poor public housing, inadequate health care, poor schools, and a disappearing employment base.”
I, for one, am willing to accept that.
I am one of the millions of American moviegoers who will pay over and over again to watch a variation on the theme of the lone outsider who rides into town, rights all wrongs, and rides off into the sunset.
But I would not pay to see a movie about a disappearing employment base.
Bulman could have produced some useful scholarship if he had, instead of trying to make the case for why Americans’ favorite fantasies are accurate reflections of their public policy attitudes, gone in either of two different, but related, directions.
It would have been genuinely useful to know what the majority of middle-class taxpayers/voters really do think the big issues confronting urban schools are, and how those might be addressed. To do this Bulman would have had to conduct some kind of sociologically valid interview or survey.
Alternatively, having identified an attitude toward the problems of urban schools and how to address them, that he disagrees with, Bulman could have investigated whether current laws and policies have been crafted with that flawed attitude in mind. This could have suggested public policy alternatives.
What I want to know is whether our public policies reflect flawed thinking about the nature of urban problems, not whether our movies do.
No comments:
Post a Comment